The potential for a local community take-over of Cairn Gorm from Highlands and Islands Enterprise

October 9, 2021 Nick Kempe 1 comment
Article from the the Strathy 7th October 2021

The Aviemore and Glenmore Community Trust (AGCT) was formed in October 2017  “to seek community ownership of the Cairngorm Ski Area and Infrastructure, in order to ensure that it is more effectively managed for mountain visitors, employees, and the local and wider community”. 

That purpose was recorded at the end of the minutes of their first AGM, almost three years ago in November 2018:

Mike Gale closed the meeting by thanking members for attending the meeting and reiterating that AGCT’s goal was a future successful ski area at Cairngorm Mountain”

It is still still reflected in the banner headline on the AGCT website:

http://www.aviemoreglenmoretrust.org/

Highlands and Islands Enterprise (HIE)’s response to the creation of the Trust and the potential takeover of their property at Cairngorm was first, in 2019, to offer the AGCT grant money to employ staff (see here) but then to ward off their attentions from Cairn Gorm.  Parkswatch contributors thought the AGCT had made a major mistake when, at HIE’s instigation, they decided in 2020 to take on a totally different project, an ice rink in Aviemore (see here).  We thought this would embroil the AGCT in a project they could never deliver and divert their attentions from the key issue, the future of downhill skiing at Cairn Gorm.

I am happy to admit that we were wrong on the first part.  Eighteen months ago the AGCT had almost no cash but since then it has raised £110,000, of which over £60,000 has come from the community and local business donations.

It has secured a site, free of charge for seven months, and planning permission (see here) for the rink, near the site of the old rink which was demolished and where  permission had been granted  to build a new rink twenty years ago:

But perhaps most important of all has been the way the project has engaged and invigorated the local community (see the excellent facebook page https://www.facebook.com/AviemoreCommunityIce/).
There is a long way to go of course.  The AGCT hopes to create nine jobs paying the Scottish Living Wage (not a lot but higher than many of the low paid tourist jobs in the Cairngorms National Park) but for that they need the general public to use the rink.  If that does succeed this winter, there will be a number of challenges, which include:
  • finding/negotiating a more permanent site and one that is affordable, the risk being that if the rink becomes successful MacDonald Resorts or other potential landowners will hike the rent. That might put community land-ownership back onto AGCT’s agenda.
  • making the ice rink sustainable in terms of energy use (I think it was right the Cairngorms National Park Authority has contributed £25k but from the Green Recovery Fund?).
  • and whether the AGCT can develop the capacity to turn its attentions back to Cairn Gorm.
While the ice-rink project has clearly diverted AGCT from Cairn Gorm for the last couple of years, in retrospect that is not necessarily a bad thing.  I very much doubt they could have persuaded HIE to change any of the disastrous decisions it has taken in that time or that HIE would have allowed them to take on any of the business up there.  What everyone should now be able to see, from members of the local community to national politicians like Kate Forbes, MSP, is that the AGCT would have made a much better job than HIE of operating the  “side attractions” at Cairn Gorm, like the campervan park in Coire na Ciste (see here).
The risk now is that HIE tries to co-opt the AGCT to help run the Cairngorm Mountain Scotland Ltd without giving it any power.  I hope the AGCT resists that, maintains its independence and, as I have suggested, makes a bid to takeover Coire na Ciste, since HIE has decided to end skiing there.  They would be well advised, however, to leave HIE to manage the disaster of the funicular in Coire Cas and wait for national politicians to decide to sort out that mess.

1 Comment on “The potential for a local community take-over of Cairn Gorm from Highlands and Islands Enterprise

  1. I think that the idea for AGCT (or some other community trust) to take over Corie na Ciste makes a lot of sense. The big problem is that the last thing that HIE and CMSL want is competition on their doorstep. After all such a move would just show up how inept HIE and CMSL have been over the years in their muddled attempts to run Cairngorm Mountain.
    I will go further and say that unless a community trust like AGCT is given the support and freedom to develop Corie na Ciste – with the motorhome park, winter sports and as a nature centre, Cairngorm Mountain as a tourism attraction is dead. The planning of the future of public use of the mountain of Cairn Gorm MUST be taken away from HIE. When will the Scottish Government waken up to this fact.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *