Glen Falloch hydro penstock makeover starts

 

A year after Parkswatch first started to cover the hydro schemes in Glen Falloch and highlighted thefailure of the Loch Lomond and Trossachs National Park Authority to follow its own best practice guidance  (see here) that penstock and other materials should wherever possible be in colours that blend into the natural environment, the penstock above the A82 has been painted.    A belated well done to the planners!

 

The improvement though, to my mind highlights the light concrete which holds the penstock in place and will take years to weather.  Why can’t the LLTNPA also get Falloch Estates to face the concrete with natural materials as per its own Guidance?

 

I had asked the LLTNPA what is was going to do about the penstock last year and received this non-committal answer which failed even to admit that anything had gone wrong:

 

Its good therefore the LLTNPA has implicitly recognised that blue penstock are not good enough but it  has a long way to go in Glen Falloch if all the penstock are to be painted.  While the Eas Eonan hydro pipe is buried below this penstock, it then emerges to cross the River Falloch and the penstock there is still bright blue.  Not visible from the A82  but highly visible from the West Highland Way.

Penstock crossing Falloch between two metal girders – photo taken from just below A82

I also noticed driving up the A82 that the blue penstock crossing the Alt Chuilinn (and part of that scheme) is still  bright Lomond blue – the pipe (photo left) should have been placed underneath the bridge but again the LLTNPA ignored its own guidance.   I think its fair to say therefore that the makeover of the penstock  has only just started.   That it has taken a year to get this far demonstrates a lack of will but the basic problem is the LLTNPA has allowed the Glen Falloch schemes to be developed with inadequate specifications in place (blue penstock that needed painting should have never been allowed) and then has not been properly monitored.

 

There is a real risk the Park will run out of time to ensure the schemes meet its own Guidance – it has three years to ensure the planning conditions are met – as has happened with the award winning Allt Fionn scheme (which I visited on Friday and will cover in future post).

1 Comment on “Glen Falloch hydro penstock makeover starts

  1. It’s difficult to see but looking at the comparison between the two first photographs of the Glen Falloch pen stock, it would appear that the tree planting for screening has failed to establish growth and to all intents and purposes seems to have died back so that’s another item for the enforcement team.
    There is a definite lack of follow up by the planning authority in many of these planning applications and it seems any site visit to check compliance is the exception to the rule. With these large destructive projects that is just unacceptable. How are we every going to have our Glens restored at lest on the path to their former Glory if the park does not enforce it’s own conditions within the time frame.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *